Feb+4,+2011

1296172865

Hi guys here is the paper. Questions coming soon.

I would like to change the schedule a little bit. Please answer the question by Tuesday and reply on wednesday. Then I will have another short exercise for you on thursday.

Ivan

1296751744 As you can imagine, there was quite a lot of controversy surrounding this paper. no fewer than 3 responses were published in Nature: see the papers page [|here]

of particular interest was this [|reply] and the Lolle et al. [|response]

two other notable responses were and

please read over the responses. You don't need to disect them completely, we will still focus our discussion on Lolle, but these responses are good to keep in mind.

see you tomorrow.